Why did Sean skip the Galaxy S8? Click on right here.

César Salza/Proinertech

Final March, I declared I would not purchase a Samsung Galaxy S8. I might choose a Pixel as a substitute.

However there was one factor I wasn’t relying on, one chance I hadn’t even thought-about: Google’s new cellphone would possibly ditch the headphone jack.

Yeah, it might be fairly bizarre. In any case, wasn’t Google the one who made enjoyable of Apple for doing that precise factor final 12 months?

I hope it is not true. 

As a result of this is the factor, Google: For those who kill my headphone jack, I will not purchase your cellphone both.

Wi-fi headphones aren’t prepared

“Who wants a headphone jack,” you is likely to be pondering. “Why do not you simply use Bluetooth headphones as a substitute?”

I might. Bluetooth audio is not unhealthy as of late — till you neglect to cost your headphones. Or lose them. Or run into wi-fi interference, which not often does occur. And that assumes you are prepared to pay additional for a Bluetooth headset to start with.

Me? I purchased an expensive pair of superior Bose QC25 noise-canceling headphones, with a wired three.5mm cable, lower than two years in the past — pondering I might be set for years to come back. That is to not point out my Grados and a number of other units of wired earbuds. 

I’ve invested an honest amount of cash in conventional headphones, and I might actually like to make use of them.

The wired Bose QuietComfort 25 was Proinertech’s high choose for noise-canceling headphones till its successor, the QC35, added Bluetooth as effectively.

Sarah Tew/Proinertech

I’ve generally toyed with the concept of making an attempt really wi-fi earbuds, however I hear that solely Apple’s AirPods are value a rattling. Until you are prepared to fork over a whole lot extra, that’s — although we’ll be testing new Bose and Samsung wi-fi units quickly.

Other than the truth that I would not be caught lifeless with Apple’s dangling eartubes, I am primarily an Android and Home windows man. Apple’s wi-fi ‘buds would technically work, however I would not get all their options.

Extra common than USB

In addition to, there is a good cause for me to maintain on trucking with wired three.5mm headphones — the jacks are in every single place. They’re in my Xbox One and PlayStation four recreation controllers, my laptop computer (even MacBooks, I would add), my desktop, and each flight I take. They’re in fairly just a few of the automobiles on the highway.

Proinertech’s Scott Stein shot to the highest of Reddit on this Apple AirPods meme. I’ve gotta agree with Leo right here.

Reddit consumer mcdswimr

Critically: The three.5mm audio jack is extra common than the USB port itself. In any case, there are eight totally different USB ports nonetheless in use. (The “U” in USB stands for “Common,” in case you did not know.)

Sure, Bluetooth is changing into practically as ubiquitous — however once we’re speaking in regards to the breadth of units available on the market, Bluetooth is not not practically so simple as plugging in a stable, mechanical jack. 

Pairing and unpairing Bluetooth units remains to be usually a ache within the ass — notably in automobiles — and never all Bluetooth units supply the identical wi-fi vary. (It is approach simpler and extra dependable to plug wired headphones into my PS4 controller than use a Bluetooth set.)

#donglelife is just not for me

So what in regards to the dongle, Sean? I am so glad you requested — “dongle” is unquestionably certainly one of my favourite phrases within the English language. Virtually each headphone-jack-less cellphone technically does include a three.5mm headphone jack — on the tip of a inch-long converter cable that makes use of USB or Lightning to plug it into your cellphone.

(Such dongles even have tiny digital-to-analog converters — DACs — inside which might theoretically make my wired headphones sound higher sometime.)

No thanks.

Josh Miller/Proinertech

However I’ve lived the #donglelife, and it is not for me. Once I reviewed the Important Cellphone and inevitably wanted to plug in a pair of headphones, I discovered I might absentmindedly left the dongle in a drawer at dwelling. And once I purchased Google’s very first Android cellphone from 2008 — which, coincidentally, did not have a headphone jack — I utterly misplaced its loopy three.5mm-to-ExtUSB dongle. I nonetheless do not know the place or how.

I suppose I might simply go away a dongle related to my Bose cans 24/7. However the first time I attempt to plug these headphones into one thing else, I am going to should take away that dongle, and I do not essentially belief myself to place it again once more. And I chafe on the concept of simply shopping for a half-dozen dongles (roughly $7 a pop) and leaving them in all my luggage, my desk at work, and at dwelling.

A matter of precept

None of those causes are really why I might abandon my desires of Pixel-y goodness, although.

My actual cause is a matter of precept. There’s merely no good cause for Google to desert the headphone jack. No person’s asking for it to go away.

The T-Cell G1 (aka HTC Dream), the primary Android cellphone. keyboard. three.5-inch display screen. No headphone jack — which was uncommon again then. Plus that loopy chin.


The lack of the headphone jack looks like yet one more alternative that is being pressured on smartphone house owners — one other approach telephones are being hammered into types which can be roughly indistinguishable from one another.

Keep in mind when QWERTY keyboards had been an possibility? Keep in mind when flagship telephones with small screens had been, too?

These issues went away not as a result of cellphone patrons had been asking for larger screens and software program keyboards, however as a result of cellphone makers and mobile carriers wanted large, daring options to drive a brand new improve cycle. Huge screens trumped all the pieces else.

Killing off the headphone jack is arguably even worse, as a result of we’re seemingly getting nothing in return. We lose assured compatibility with numerous thousands and thousands of audio units for what, precisely?

It does not make a cellphone a lot thinner to take away it, and telephones are skinny sufficient anyhow. Present me a brick with a three-day battery and an indestructible case, and I am going to present you a contented camper. (Actually — I am going to take it tenting.) Possibly if an organization was eliminating all its ports — a wirelessly charging cellphone with wi-fi USB — I might perceive it. However that is not a actuality but.

The Google Pixel XL. We would like fairly just a few issues from its successor — the three.5mm jack is only one of them.

Josh Miller

Sure, I do know I am portray myself right into a nook right here. I’ve rejected Samsung, and now I am rejecting telephones sans headphone jack as effectively. However I’ve caught to my weapons earlier than, and I am going to persist with them once more. I might love a Pixel 2, however I am going to purchase an LG V30, a OnePlus 5 or a Moto Z2 Play — all of which have customary headphone jacks — if I actually should.

Name me when Bluetooth headphones are simply pretty much as good — hell, higher — than wired ones. Name me once they’re so reasonably priced producers throw them within the field at no additional cost, and once they’re simply as simple to “plug in”. Name me when cellphone producers use the house they save on a headphone jack for one thing significant.

However in case you name me after Oct. four, it’s possible you’ll not attain me on a Google Pixel.

I refuse to be complicit within the headphone’s jack’s loss of life for no good cause in any respect. 

5 new Google devices the web simply spoiled: Hey Google, your units are displaying.

What I need within the Google Pixel 2: Proinertech’s Lynn La weighs in. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.